Image Source: insideevs.com

For many urban commuters, the daily grind of traffic can transform even a picturesque route into a source of constant frustration. Lucian Capellaro, for instance, faces a particularly challenging commute through Laurel Canyon, stretching from the San Fernando Valley to Los Los Angeles’ west end. This daily ordeal has made him keenly aware of advanced driver assistance systems.

Capellaro found himself listening intently as colleagues lauded the capabilities of Tesla’s Full Self-Driving (FSD) feature. The promise of merely inputting a destination and having the vehicle navigate the route sounded like a revolutionary solution. However, a personal preference for car design, interior quality, and body style, beyond any political considerations, kept him from considering a Tesla.

An imminent alternative from Mercedes-Benz could soon address this need. The German luxury automaker is preparing to introduce its MB.Drive Assist Pro point-to-point automated driving system. This advanced Mercedes automated driving system is slated for integration into a significant portion of the brand’s electric and internal combustion vehicle lineup early next year, with existing eligible vehicles receiving the feature via an over-the-air (OTA) update.

Key Takeaways: Mercedes-Benz MB.Drive Assist Pro

  • Mercedes-Benz is launching its MB.Drive Assist Pro system, a direct competitor to Tesla’s Full Self-Driving (Supervised), available early next year for both electric and internal combustion vehicles via OTA updates.
  • The primary distinction lies in driver engagement: MB.Drive Assist Pro requires drivers to keep a hand on the wheel on surface streets, while permitting hands-free operation on controlled-access highways. Tesla FSD (Supervised) allows hands-free driving on both.
  • Mercedes attributes this requirement to a strict adherence to the Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE) Level 2 definition, emphasizing driver responsibility on complex surface streets.
  • Unlike Tesla’s camera-centric approach, Mercedes’ automated driving system incorporates five radar sensors and 12 ultrasonic sensors alongside cameras, with plans for LiDAR at Level 3, highlighting a multi-sensor strategy for enhanced safety.
  • Driver feedback is divided, with some valuing the safety of hands-on control, while experienced Tesla FSD users prefer the freedom of hands-off driving, even indicating reluctance to switch if a hands-on requirement existed.
  • Ultimately, the system’s real-world performance and its ability to build user trust, alongside overall vehicle attributes like comfort and value, will determine its market acceptance.

Introducing the Mercedes Automated Driving System

Mercedes’ MB.Drive Assist Pro, much like Tesla’s FSD (Supervised), is designed to navigate a vehicle from a specified starting point to a destination, including parking functionalities. This comprehensive driver assistance technology aims to significantly alleviate driving burdens.

However, a crucial operational difference sets the two systems apart. While both allow for hands-free driving on controlled-access highways, the Mercedes automated driving system mandates that drivers maintain a hand on the steering wheel when traversing surface streets. This requirement contrasts with Tesla FSD, which permits hands-off operation in a broader range of environments.

The Philosophical Divide: SAE Autonomy Levels

This functional distinction does not necessarily indicate an inferiority of the Mercedes system but rather reflects a fundamental philosophical approach to autonomous driving. Mercedes-Benz adheres rigorously to the Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE) definitions for autonomous driving levels, a framework widely recognized within the automotive industry.

Both MB.Drive Assist Pro and Tesla FSD (Supervised) are categorized as Level 2 systems, or what Mercedes refers to as “Level 2 Plus Plus.” This classification means that the driver must remain actively supervised and ready to take control at all times.

Jörg Burzer, Mercedes Chief Technology Officer, articulated the importance of these distinctions to InsideEVs: “There is a very important borderline between the levels. That borderline is that with Level 2 Plus Plus, you are responsible. At Level 3, the machine, the car, the software stack, is responsible.”

Navigating the Complexities of Surface Streets

Burzer further explained that controlled-access highways present a comparatively more predictable and less variable environment for a Level 2 system to manage. In contrast, surface streets are characterized by significantly higher levels of chaos and complexity, involving unpredictable pedestrian movements, varied traffic patterns, and numerous intersections.

Consequently, to ensure safety and adhere to their interpretation of Level 2 responsibilities, Mercedes mandates driver engagement with a hand on the wheel when the vehicle operates off highways. This hands-on requirement is a core tenet of the Mercedes automated driving system when deployed in urban or suburban settings.

Driver Perspectives: Hands-On vs. Hands-Off

The decision to require hands-on engagement on surface streets appears logical to some drivers, including Capellaro, despite his self-admitted risk-taking as a motorcycle rider. He notes, “Think about the reaction time it must be for someone to take their hands from off the wheel to on the wheel. I’d view my hand on the wheel as lessening the seconds of reaction time to something crazy happening.”

Customer research conducted by Mercedes indicates that European drivers largely share Capellaro’s sentiment regarding this safety protocol. Burzer observed, “In the city, they like to have something, some regulation or some requirement that you have to have a hand on the wheel,” though he acknowledged uncertainty about U.S. customer preferences.

Skepticism from Tesla FSD Users

However, when pressed on why a driver would choose the Mercedes automated driving system over Tesla’s offering, which permits hands-off operation on surface streets, Burzer reiterated the emphasis on regulatory compliance and strict adherence to SAE autonomy levels, often circling back to the eventual advent of Level 3 capabilities.

“The big question is when is level 3 coming?” he insisted. “Because then you can have the hands off (anywhere).” Many Tesla FSD users, it seems, believe their vehicles already operate at a functional level akin to Level 3, diverging from Mercedes’ stringent interpretation of SAE definitions.

Antonio Hidalgo, another Los Angeles resident and frequent FSD user, uses the system extensively for various driving tasks. He has even managed to take naps while driving, protected by a hat and sunglasses, indicating a high level of trust. Hidalgo primarily identifies parking as the only remaining flaw in the Tesla system.

When asked if he would switch to the Mercedes automated driving system if it performed similarly but required hands on the wheel, Hidalgo pondered. “You know, I probably wouldn’t (make the switch). I mean, I think I would be interested in having a nicer car with a better interior. But no.”

Similarly, Mharlon Barrientos, who uses FSD for his commute in Indianapolis, described an evolution in his trust. Initially, he would “hover” a hand near the wheel. Now, thanks to system updates and experience, he operates fully hands-off.

“Having a hand on the wheel as a requirement would be a bit of a step back to the feel of full autonomous driving that I’ve gotten used,” Barrientos stated, recalling that his Model Y originally required hands on the wheel for the system to function.

The Sensor Suite Debate: A Multi-Sensor Approach

Mercedes-Benz is quick to highlight what it perceives as a significant advantage of its MB.Drive Assist Pro over Tesla’s FSD (Supervised). The Mercedes automated driving system does not solely rely on cameras for obstacle detection, unlike Tesla’s approach. Instead, it employs a sophisticated sensor fusion strategy.

The system integrates five radar sensors and 12 ultrasonic sensors, which feed raw data into the car’s Nvidia-powered computer, complementing the visual input from cameras. This comprehensive sensor array aims to provide a more robust and redundant perception of the environment.

Christoph von Hugo, Mercedes’ Head of Active Safety, underscored this philosophy, stating, “Different sensor inputs increases performance and safety.” He added, in what appeared to be an indirect reference to Tesla’s methodology, that “Relying on one just is not enough.” Mercedes has also stated that it will not advance to Level 3 capability without incorporating LiDAR technology, in addition to its existing camera, radar, and ultrasonic sensors.

User Trust vs. Technical Specifications

However, the technical superiority of a multi-sensor approach may not be the ultimate deciding factor for consumers. Barrientos expressed skepticism about the selling power of sensor specifications alone. “I honestly haven’t even thought about the tech behind it, so I’m not so sure knowing that there’s radar and ultra-sonic sensors (on the window sticker) would be a huge selling point,” he commented.

He suggested that real-world performance, demonstrated through videos or reviews, and extensive personal experience would be crucial for building trust. “Just like the Tesla system, I think it would take me some mileage on both highway and streets to gain a trust for the system to know it’ll handle either situation well.”

Barrientos also clarified that his loyalty is not solely to Tesla or FSD. Many Tesla owners prioritize overall vehicle attributes beyond just the advanced driver assistance features.

Beyond Autonomy: Holistic Vehicle Appeal

“The hands-on requirement in the city would not be enough to sway me off of the car provided I like the rest of the car,” Barrientos affirmed. “While I like the functionality of FSD, it’s still a bit further down the list of what I look for in a car. Functionality, comfort, value … I still like to feel the mechanics and have the feel of actually driving a car.”

Capellero echoes this sentiment. He questions how much of a functional leap the Mercedes automated driving system would represent compared to his wife’s BMW i4, which already offers adaptive cruise control and hands-free highway driving assist in low-speed traffic. His ultimate decision hinges on real-world performance.

“I guess I’d just have to experience (MB.Drive Assist Pro) for myself, but if it can navigate all the craziness that is Laurel Canyon through Hollywood, and it is literally just my hand resting on the wheel, and that’s it, then sure,” he said. “The fact that it’s truly point-to-point, then yes, that sounds super appealing.”

The Road Ahead: Performance, Trust, and Acceptance

The pivotal question remains: will the Mercedes automated driving system, MB.Drive Assist Pro, deliver a level of performance comparable to Tesla FSD, despite its hands-on requirement in urban settings? While early passenger-seat experiences in San Francisco in January showed promise, a comprehensive review of the system’s full capabilities is eagerly anticipated.

The debate over whether a hands-on requirement is ultimately beneficial or a hindrance for advanced driver assistance systems will likely continue. The market’s reception will depend not only on technical prowess and safety protocols but also on how seamlessly these features integrate into the overall driving experience and build enduring driver trust. Stay tuned for further insights into this evolving landscape of vehicle autonomy.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What is Mercedes-Benz MB.Drive Assist Pro?

MB.Drive Assist Pro is Mercedes-Benz’s upcoming point-to-point automated driving system. It is designed to navigate vehicles to a specified destination, including parking. It will be available on numerous Mercedes electric and internal combustion models, with existing eligible vehicles receiving it via over-the-air updates early next year.

How does MB.Drive Assist Pro differ from Tesla Full Self-Driving (FSD) in operation?

The key difference lies in driver engagement on surface streets. While both systems allow hands-free driving on controlled-access highways, MB.Drive Assist Pro requires drivers to keep a hand on the steering wheel when operating on surface streets, a distinction from Tesla FSD (Supervised) which permits hands-off driving in such conditions.

Why does Mercedes require hands on the wheel on surface streets?

Mercedes-Benz adheres strictly to the Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE) Level 2 definition for automated driving. Its Chief Technology Officer, Jörg Burzer, stated that at Level 2, the driver remains responsible. Surface streets present more complex and chaotic environments, necessitating greater driver supervision and readiness to intervene.

What sensor technology does Mercedes MB.Drive Assist Pro use?

The Mercedes automated driving system employs a comprehensive sensor suite. It integrates five radar sensors, 12 ultrasonic sensors, and cameras, all feeding data to an Nvidia-powered computer. Mercedes believes this multi-sensor approach enhances performance and safety, distinguishing it from Tesla’s camera-centric system.

Will Mercedes-Benz offer a Level 3 autonomous driving system?

Mercedes-Benz has indicated that it will only ascend to Level 3 autonomous driving capability by adding LiDAR technology to its existing array of cameras, radar, and ultrasonic sensors. This commitment underscores their cautious and multi-faceted approach to achieving higher levels of vehicle autonomy.

Do drivers prefer a hands-on or hands-off automated driving system?

Driver preferences vary. Some, like Lucian Capellaro and many European drivers, appreciate the safety aspect of keeping hands on the wheel, reducing reaction time. However, many experienced Tesla FSD users prefer hands-off operation, finding the hands-on requirement a step back from a fully autonomous driving feel they’ve become accustomed to.

What factors influence a driver’s decision to adopt an advanced driving system?

Beyond the technical capabilities of the automated driving system, factors like overall vehicle functionality, comfort, value, and the ‘feel of actually driving a car’ significantly influence a driver’s decision. User trust, built through extensive real-world experience, is also a critical element for widespread adoption.

Created with ❤